I could have guessed it was all to shove it in my face.

Don't bring up religion to me in person. It's awkward. To the people who like to tell me their religious denomination at random; I'm not stupid. I know you're trying to get me to say the words, "I'm an Atheist" which will give you full power to trash my beliefs (or lack thereof). I'd love to hear you talk about your religion, I truly find that fascinating. For the most part, other religions have my respect.

All I'm asking for is a little bit of respect in return. "Oh, you're still being stupid about that?"